Cold Plunges: Separating Hype from Science

🧊Cold plunges are everywhere on social media. But what does science actually say about ice baths?

In this first episode, we explore:

• The rise of cold plunges and where the hype began (spoiler: podcasts, dopamine, and Wim Hof ).

• What the science actually says about mood, metabolism, inflammation, immunity, and longevity.

• Where the benefits are real — and where influencers are seriously overreaching.

• The hidden downsides: blunted muscle growth, overhyped fat loss, and actual health risks.

• Who might benefit (athletes, anxious minds, metabolic tuning) — and who should skip the ice.

Let’s jump in (pun)!

1. Popular Claims & Where They Originated

Cold plunges (2–10 minute immersions in ~10–15°C water) are touted to “do everything” for health​. Common claims include: improved mood and mental health, reduced inflammation and faster recovery, boosted metabolism and fat loss via brown fat, enhanced immunity (fewer colds), and even anti-aging or longevity effects.

I remember the first time I heard about it ( either Joe Rogan or Andrew Huberman), and I jumped in the (literally) the pool (boy was I wrong!).

The OG of ice-baths is “Iceman” Wim Hof, who popularised cold exposure by claiming it boosts immune resistance; this was amplified on podcasts and documentaries. Likewise, neuroscientist Andrew Huberman’s podcast cited a study showing dopamine levels spiked 250% after an hour-long icy bath – leading him to claim that even brief cold exposure causes a “lasting increase in dopamine and sustained elevation of mood”​. Such soundbites spread widely on social media, fueling the notion that a daily cold plunge is a quick biohack for happiness and focus.

However, many origins trace back to specific but narrow studies or athletic practices that have been generalised. The dopamine finding, for instance, came from a 2000 experiment immersing people in 14°C water for an hour​. Claims of reduced inflammation stem from sports medicine: for decades, athletes took ice baths after games to curb soreness and swelling. This practice (effective for short-term recovery) was extrapolated by wellness gurus to mean cold plunges fight chronic inflammation or joint pain in anyone. Similarly, the idea that cold boosts metabolism and burns fat arose after scientists discovered adult humans have brown adipose tissue (BAT). Around 2009–2010, studies showed cold exposure activates BAT to burn calories (through shivering), and early biohackers (e.g. authors of popular diet books) seized on this as a fat-loss tactic. These claims often mixed animal research and human physiology: e.g. lab mice living in cooler temperatures live longer, so some longevity enthusiasts speculated that regular cold exposure might slow aging in humans (not true)​.

A lot of the so called benefits are… to put it lightly… BS and inflated through an influencer echo chamber. I’ll give you a few examples and we can jump into what the science actually says:

• a widely repeated claim is that cold showers “boost your immune system” – often referencing a Dutch study where people who took daily cold showers had 29% fewer sick-day absences from work​. That study got attention on news sites and podcasts, sometimes glossing over that it relied on self-reported illness and a health-aware sample.

• other claims (improved mood, immunity, longevity) that have been passed along by wellness gurus and social media, sometimes based on personal experiments or loosely related research (like elite athlete studies or rodent data). As one scientific review noted, “popular literature… claimed [cold water] can boost the immune system, treat depression… burn calories and reduce stress,” but “many of the proclaimed benefits are based on subjective claims and anecdotal cases.” (https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9518606/#:~:text=Ice%20bathing%20has%20been%20suggested,subjective%20claims%20and%20anecdotal%20cases)

In short, cold plunges’ fame grew from a mix of intriguing science, traditional practices, and charismatic advocates – but we must examine if the science truly backs the hype.

2. What Science Actually Says (Evidence Breakdown)

Research on cold-water immersion (CWI) has expanded in the past 10–15 years (and so has the number of participants) testing these claims in labs and clinical trials. Overall, the evidence paints a nuanced picture: some benefits are real (mostly short-term or specific scenarios), others are unproven, and a few claims are outright not true. Here’s a breakdown by area, emphasizing recent peer-reviewed studies:

• Inflammation and Recovery: Paradoxically, exposing your body to cold water triggers an acute stress response – blood levels of certain inflammatory markers (like IL-6) actually increase immediately after a cold plunge​. This is similar to how exercise briefly spikes inflammation as a hormetic stress. A 2025 systematic review found CWI causes a significant short-term inflammatory response (within an hour) but may help lower subjective stress levels by ~12 hours post-immersion​ (pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov).
  
  Many athletes swear by ice baths to reduce muscle soreness, and controlled trials support this: a meta-analysis of 52 studies found cold immersion reliably reduces muscle soreness and creatine kinase (muscle damage enzyme) 24 hours after intense exercise, while improving muscle power recovery​. In other words, for exercise recovery, science agrees that cold water can help you feel and perform better the next day ( big emphasis on recovery, as we’ll see later… not growth!).
  

  

  
  On the flip side, longer-term inflammation (chronic inflammation linked to diseases) is harder to study. Some small studies show a release of anti-inflammatory cytokines during cold exposure and suggest repeated cold swims might lower resting inflammation, but results are mixed and often rely on lab markers​. The data are “promising, but nothing really definitive” on whether CWI meaningfully reduces chronic inflammation over time​.

• Metabolism, Blood Sugar, and Fat Loss: This one was surprising to me actually. There is strong evidence that cold exposure can acutely boost metabolism and improve insulin sensitivity. When you immerse in cold water, your body works harder to maintain core temperature – one study documented a 350% increase in metabolic rate during a 14°C immersion​ (pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov).
  

  In practice, shivering muscles burn glucose for heat, and brown fat tissue activates to produce heat by burning calories. Research shows that shivering is key: “You’re activating your muscles through shivering and that causes responses very similar to exercise,” explains one physiologist​ (npr.org). Multiple studies (including cold-room and cooling suit experiments) have found improved insulin sensitivity for 24–48 hours after cold exposure​. In fact, some results were surprisingly robust – in one review, cold exposure improved insulin sensitivity even more than a single exercise session would​ npr.org.
  
  That said, while cold exposure does burn extra calories and can activate brown fat, the effect isn’t large enough to magically shed pounds. A journalist put it as: “Cold exposure on its own hasn’t been shown to be effective for weight loss.”​ npr.org
  

  You might burn an extra few hundred calories with a long shiver, but most people compensate by eating more, and the body’s adaptation limits how much brown fat one can develop. It does look like the muscle activity (shivering) contributes far more to glucose uptake and calorie burn than brown fat does. In short, cold plunges do ramp up metabolism and can make your muscles more insulin-sensitive (a positive for metabolic health), but there’s no clinical evidence that they produce significant fat loss. Any weight management benefits are anecdotal and based on not overeating afterwards (
  

• Mood and Mental Wellbeing: This is one of those topics where the science and the hype part ways. Anecdotally, people rave about the mood boost from a cold plunge — that post-dip high where everything suddenly feels sharper, lighter, more alive. And to be fair, the biology checks out: cold exposure spikes stress hormones and neurotransmitters. Norepinephrine can rise 2–5x, and dopamine — the "feel-good" chemical — can jump 2.5x after sustained cold exposure. That surge is likely behind the immediate jolt of euphoria devotees talk about (pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov).
  

  But here’s the catch: controlled studies don’t back up long-term mood improvements. A recent systematic review of randomized trials found, in plain terms, “no significant effects on mood.” Even though the stories are compelling, researchers point out there’s “very little evidence” that cold water leads to measurable improvements in mental health. Most of what we have comes from small case studies or personal anecdotes. Take the often-cited BMJ report: one woman with major depression started open-water swims, felt better, and eventually tapered off antidepressants. Amazing? Yes. Scientific proof? Not quite.
  

  Much of the evidence so far comes from qualitative reports and small case studies. For example, a case report in BMJ described a young woman with major depression who began weekly open-water swims; she had immediate mood improvements after each swim and was able to taper off antidepressants over time​

  ncbi.nlm.nih.gov. This inspiring story made headlines, but as a single case it only suggests potential. Larger trials are just now starting.
  
  Until such data arrives, the scientific consensus on mood is, bottom line, if cold plunges lift your spirits, enjoy the ride — but don’t expect them to replace therapy just yet.
  

• Immune Function: Claims that cold immersion “improves immunity” (e.g. fewer colds or stronger immune system generally) are popular in wellness circles, but the evidence here is shaky and inconclusive. What studies typically measure are changes in immune cell counts or proteins after cold exposure. Some experiments show that immediately after a cold plunge, certain white blood cells. One trial found that after 6 weeks of routine 1-hour cold baths, participants had higher counts of T helper cells and certain cytokines at rest, hinting at an “immune training” effect​ (pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov).
  
  The jury is still out though. Other studies found no significant immune changes from cold bathing​ (npr.org). And crucially, measuring immune markers in blood doesn’t necessarily translate to fewer actual infections – that’s much harder to prove. A review of the evidence concluded results are “mixed” and often confounded by the fact that many study subjects are winter swimmers who also exercise regularly (exercise itself boosts immunity)​ npr.org (causality or correlation?). Real-world data is scarce: the best we have is that Dutch cold-shower study, where people who ended their showers cold did report 29% fewer sick absences from work​ npr.org. Notably, they did not report being sick fewer days – they may have simply endured illness better or had a placebo-driven resilience.
  
  In short, it’s possible that habitual cold exposure slightly bolsters your immune defenses (some researchers talk about cold as a mild stress that might increase antioxidant levels or activate virus-fighting cells), but scientists like Dr. Ottawa Haman emphasize that this claim remains “totally unclear.”​

  
  Pushing beyond an optimal dose can even backfire: if you stay in frigid water too long, you risk hypothermia and reducing immune capacity​. The bottom line from current studies: some immune markers shift with cold exposure, but we don’t have clear evidence that cold plungers get sick less often in a meaningful way​.
  

(Wim Hof … probably the godfather of CWI)

• Longevity and Other Claims: The idea that cold plunging can help you live longer? Mostly wishful thinking with a side of extrapolation. While it’s true that in various animal models cooler core body temperatures correlate with longer life (worms, flies, and mice live longer with mild cold stress)​ (nature.com), applying this to humans is tricky. No human study has tracked cold-bathing habits over a lifetime to see if it adds years (admittedly it’s always really difficult with anything longevity related).

  
  Most longevity claims are really just piggybacking on known benefits — like improved metabolic health or inflammation control — that might, theoretically, extend healthspan (not lifespan). But those benefits aren’t unique to cold. You can get them from diet, sleep, and regular workouts without needing to shock your system every morning.
  
  Other claims — like improved sleep or better focus — are slightly more credible. One small trial showed cool showers might improve sleep quality (for men, anyway). And adrenaline definitely spikes after a plunge, which is why cold showers work better than coffee for some folks. As for “resilience,” researchers suggest that repeatedly braving cold trains your nervous system to bounce back from stress faster. A few brief plunges can even blunt your cold shock response for months. One study found that cold-exposed folks handled high-altitude stress better, which is… oddly specific, but interesting. news-medical.net.

  
  All together, the scientific consensus in 2025 is that some of the cold plunge hype is justified – particularly for exercise recovery, metabolic boosts, and a short-term mental uplift. But… when it comes to claims around immunity, long-term mood improvements, or lifespan extension, the science is just not there. As one review put it, the studies are all over the place: different methods, tiny sample sizes, and short durations. Translation: we’ve got signals, not conclusions.

3. The Case For Cold Plunging

A. Legit Recovery Hack (If You Actually Need One)
Cold water immersion reduces muscle soreness and helps you recover faster after intense training — that’s not hype, that’s multiple meta-analyses, like this one. If you’re running back-to-back workouts or competing, this can mean the difference between bouncing back or dragging. It’s not magic, but it works when used smartly — particularly for short-term recovery, not long-term adaptation.

B. Mood and Energy Boost You Can Feel
That “alive” feeling people rave about after a plunge? It’s real. Cold spikes norepinephrine (hello, alertness) and dopamine (aka motivation and reward), sometimes by 2–2.5x (HubermanLab breakdown). Even if it doesn’t cure depression, many people feel better afterward. The short-term clarity and energy boost is one of the most consistent and believable effects.

C. A Metabolic Nudge — Not a Fat-Loss Miracle
Shivering burns calories. Brown fat gets activated. Insulin sensitivity improves. Studies show cold can boost your metabolic rate and glucose uptake for 24–48 hours post-immersion (source). For those managing blood sugar or sedentary days, it’s a solid physiological stimulus. Just don’t expect six-pack abs from sitting in a tub — cold plunges are additive, not transformative.

---

4. The Case Against

A. Overhyped and Underproven for Most People
The dopamine hit is real… but lasting improvements in mood or immunity? Not so much. Reviews like this 2022 umbrella review of 104 studies found the benefits often hinge on small sample sizes, short durations, or highly specific populations (e.g., winter swimmers, elite athletes).
Even promising findings — like improved mood or immune cell counts — are often based on self-reports or lack clinical relevance (i.e., you might have more T-cells, but does that mean fewer colds? We don’t know).
The short version: yes, cold plunges do something. But if you’re healthy, sleep well, and exercise, the ROI might be marginal.

B. Risky, Especially If You’re Not Careful (or Cardiovascularly Robust)
Let’s be blunt: dunking yourself in 5°C water isn’t benign. That initial shock spikes your blood pressure and heart rate, and for those with cardiac issues, it could be dangerous. The American Heart Association has cautioned against unsupervised cold plunging for those with cardiovascular risks. Other concerns? Hypothermia, drowning (yes, gasp reflex is a thing), nerve damage in the extremities, and that delightful phenomenon called “afterdrop” — where your core temperature keeps dropping after you get out.

Also: overusing cold plunges post-workout can actually hinder your muscle growth (goodbye gains), according to a meta-analysis that found cold therapy blunts anabolic signaling. So if gains are your goal, tread carefully.

5. The Bottom Line (Studies & Stats)

Cold water immersion has certainly earned its place in the wellness toolkit, but it’s not a miracle shortcut.

How much research is out there? A lot more than a decade ago. By 2022, over 100 human studies on cold-water immersion and health had been published​.

• These range from small experiments to systematic reviews. However, the field is still developing – many studies are pilot-sized and not all outcomes agree. A comprehensive review of 104 studies concluded that while many reported significant physiological effects, the inability to draw clear conclusions (due to inconsistent methods and quality) means debate continues on several health claims​.

• What percentage of studies show benefits vs no effect or harm? It’s hard to give exact percentages (because studies examine different endpoints), but a rough appraisal: The majority of studies (~60–70%) do observe at least one beneficial effect of cold exposure. A smaller fraction, maybe <10%, report negative effects or trade-offs. These include the studies where cold impeded muscle training gains​, or where participants experienced adverse symptoms (fainting, etc., typically in case reports rather than controlled trials). It’s also telling that one review calls the results “mixed”​ – implying roughly equal positive and null findings across many immune and health measures. In areas like athletic recovery, the balance of evidence is strongly positive (many studies in favor, few against), whereas in areas like mood or immunity, it’s more evenly split or unclear.

In other words, the science isn’t “anti-cold plunge,” it’s just… suggesting to do it if you really like it.

Takeaway: If you’re a reasonably healthy adult who exercises a few times a week, sleeps well, and eats okay, you don’t need cold plunges to be healthy. The marginal gains you might get (a bit less stress or slightly better recovery) can usually be attained by simpler, more sustainable habits. Active recovery, stretching, a hot shower, or yes — even your morning coffee — can do the job. There’s no compelling reason for everyone to hop into a tub of ice water. So, if the idea makes you shiver with dread: skip it. You’re not missing some wellness secret. Cold plunges can be a great option, but they are far from a requirement.